Alan Milburn has published a 267-page review into the growing number of young people not in education, employment or training in the UK, according to HR News. The review sets out recommendations aimed at tackling the NEET crisis and helping more young people into sustained employment.
The proposals include replacing Universal Credit for under-25s with a new Youth Allowance, halving the National Insurance threshold for employers hiring 21- to 24-year-olds in retail and hospitality, and paying employers up to £3,000 for recruiting young people who have been economically inactive for six months. Sheila Flavell CBE, COO of FDM Group, said around one million NEETs across the UK means tackling youth unemployment “must be a top government priority”.
What the review proposes for employers
The recommendations most relevant to HR and payroll teams centre on financial incentives and structural changes to youth employment. The proposed National Insurance threshold reduction would see the point at which employer contributions begin fall from £10,000 to £5,000 over five years, but only for employers hiring 21- to 24-year-olds in retail and hospitality. This is narrower than some employers may expect.
A separate proposal would introduce payments of up to £3,000 for hiring young people who have been economically inactive for six months, with an additional £2,000 incentive for recruiting young people who have been in care or are disabled. The review also recommends doubling the number of young people completing apprenticeships by 2036 and creating an additional 150,000 college places for 18- to 24-year-olds, with regional mayors working alongside employers to develop industry-led technical colleges.
How the benefits changes could affect payroll
The proposed Youth Allowance would replace Universal Credit for under-25s. For payroll teams, this matters because Universal Credit is currently administered through HMRC’s real-time information system, with earnings reported each pay period affecting the claimant’s award. A new Youth Allowance would likely require payroll systems to adapt to whatever new reporting or deduction rules accompany it, though the review does not specify the administrative mechanics.
The proposed replacement of Personal Independence Payment with two separate funds, one for ongoing disability-related costs and one for one-off expenses, could also change how some employees receive support. Employers with disabled staff or those hiring young people with disabilities should watch for consultation details, as the interaction between workplace adjustments and state support may shift.

Unknown authorUnknown author (Franz Konrad confessed to tak, Public domain
What this means for hiring young workers
The review’s modelling suggests the reforms could help around 440,000 young people into sustained work. For HR teams, the practical question is whether the proposed incentives are enough to change hiring behaviour. Sheila Flavell noted that “the first rung of the career ladder is disappearing across too many sectors due to rising costs, economic uncertainty and the rise of AI”, and that entry-level vacancies increasingly ask for experience graduates cannot obtain.
Flavell proposed extending National Insurance relief to 21- to 24-year-olds in their first two years of work, a broader measure than the review’s retail and hospitality focus. She also called for structured training from businesses that includes AI skills. Employers considering youth hiring should assess whether existing apprenticeship levy funds, combined with any future incentives, would cover the training costs involved.
Key proposals at a glance
| Proposal | Detail | Scope |
|---|---|---|
| Youth Allowance | Replace Universal Credit for under-25s | UK-wide welfare measure |
| NI threshold cut | Halve from £10,000 to £5,000 over five years | Employers hiring 21-24s in retail and hospitality |
| Hiring payments | Up to £3,000 for six-month inactive; £2,000 extra for care leavers or disabled | Employers generally |
| Apprenticeships | Double completions by 2036 | UK-wide |
| College places | 150,000 additional places for 18-24s | England, via regional mayors |
What happens next
The HR News article does not state a specific government response or implementation date. The review’s recommendations would require legislation or policy changes across the Department for Work and Pensions, HMRC and the Department for Education, so employers should not budget for the incentives yet. HR and payroll leads should monitor consultation documents and any autumn statement or budget announcements that pick up the proposals.
For now, the review signals a direction of travel: more targeted subsidies for youth hiring, closer ties between regional authorities and employers on technical education, and a benefits system designed to move under-25s into work rather than manage them outside it.
Sources: HR News
Photo: Portuguese - Citizens' Corner debate on cutting Europe's youth unemployment- Mis by euranet_plus, CC BY-SA 2.0

