HRMS News logo

Foundever unfair dismissal Australia: call centre worker wins $5,235.75

Foundever unfair dismissal Australia: call centre worker wins $5,235.75

Australia’s Fair Work Commission has found that Foundever Australia Pty Ltd unfairly dismissed a part-time customer service representative and ordered the company to pay $5,235.75 in compensation, according to OnNotice. The worker had been employed since 13 November 2017 and was summarily dismissed on 18 May 2026 over alleged call avoidance.

Foundever alleged that over several weeks the worker put customers on hold without need, passed on enquiries within their own ability to resolve, and cut calls off on purpose. The company provided the date, time and details of each call. The Commission accepted that the worker breached call handling procedures but was not satisfied the evidence showed deliberate avoidance. It found the dismissal harsh, while accepting the worker had repeatedly failed to follow call handling procedures. The worker lodged the claim under section 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 on 25 May 2026.

Why the dismissal was found harsh

The case turns on a distinction Australian employers often miss: a performance or procedure breach is not automatically serious misconduct. Foundever dismissed the worker without notice, which under the Fair Work Act 2009 is only available where the employer reasonably believes the conduct is serious enough to justify immediate termination.

The Commission accepted the procedural breaches happened. What it did not accept was the employer’s characterisation of those breaches as deliberate call avoidance. The worker handled around 70 calls a day over roughly 8.5 years. In that volume, repeated procedural failures can reflect poor habits, unclear training or inconsistent enforcement rather than intentional misconduct.

For HR teams, the practical point is that summary dismissal requires evidence of intent or recklessness, not just repeated error. Where call logs show a pattern, the employer still needs to show the worker knew the conduct was wrong and chose to do it anyway.

What this means for call centre employers

Call centres in Australia often rely on telephony data to manage performance. Metrics such as hold time, transfer rates and call duration are treated as objective evidence. This case shows the Fair Work Commission will look behind the metrics.

Foundever gave the worker the date, time and details of each call. That level of specificity is good practice. But the Commission still asked whether the data proved deliberate avoidance or simply poor call handling. The answer mattered because the dismissal was summary, with no notice period paid.

Employers running call centres for outside clients, including banking clients, face particular pressure to remove workers quickly when a client complains about call quality. That commercial pressure does not change the legal test. A dismissal can be unfair even when the employer acts in good faith on client concerns.

Foundever unfair dismissal Australia: call centre worker wins $5,235.75 (illustration)
Photo: Gen. John A. Dix and group, Sanitary Fair Commission – NARA – 524575 by Mathew Benjamin Brady, Public domain

Compensation and the five-week calculation

The Commission ordered $5,235.75, equal to five weeks’ notice. That figure reflects the worker’s part-time hours and length of service. Under the Fair Work Act, compensation for unfair dismissal is capped and calculated by reference to what the worker would have earned had they remained employed, less any earnings since dismissal.

For payroll teams, the amount is a reminder that compensation orders are not penalties. They are meant to restore lost remuneration. A five-week notice equivalent is modest compared with the cost of defending a claim and the operational disruption of replacing an experienced worker.

The worker was employed part-time from 13 November 2017 until 18 May 2026. The claim was lodged on 25 May 2026, within the 21-day statutory window. That timing matters: unfair dismissal claims under section 394 must be lodged within 21 days of the dismissal taking effect, unless the Commission grants an extension.

Item Detail
Employment period 13 November 2017 to 18 May 2026
Dismissal date 18 May 2026
Claim lodged 25 May 2026
Compensation ordered $5,235.75
Notice equivalent Five weeks

Steps for HR before a summary dismissal

The case offers a checklist for Australian employers considering summary dismissal for alleged misconduct. First, separate the procedural breach from the intent. Ask whether the evidence shows the worker deliberately avoided work or simply performed poorly. Second, review whether the worker was warned. The Commission’s finding that the dismissal was harsh suggests the worker’s history and the employer’s response to earlier breaches were relevant.

Third, consider whether dismissal without notice is proportionate. Even where serious misconduct is established, the Commission can still find a dismissal harsh if the worker’s length of service, personal circumstances or the employer’s own procedures weigh against immediate termination.

Fourth, document the decision against the specific allegations. Foundever provided call details, which helped establish the breaches occurred. What it could not establish was the mental element. HR teams should test whether their evidence supports the conclusion they want to draw before acting.

What the ruling does not decide

The Commission did not find that the worker did nothing wrong. It accepted repeated failures to follow call handling procedures. The ruling does not prevent employers from dismissing workers for poor performance or procedural breaches where they follow a fair process and give notice or payment in lieu.

It also does not set a general rule that call avoidance allegations always fail. Each case depends on the evidence. Where an employer can show a worker understood the procedures and deliberately ignored them, summary dismissal may be upheld. The difference here was the gap between what the call data showed and what the employer inferred from it.

Employers should confirm how these principles apply to their own workplace and seek advice on specific cases. The Fair Work Commission decides each matter on its facts, and state or enterprise-specific rules may add further requirements.

Sources: onnotice.com.au

Photo: Ansel Adams - Farm workers and Mt. Williamson by Ansel Adams, Public domain

administrator

Related Articles