HRMS News logo

Sixth Circuit overtime ruling favors employer in IC-to-W-2 case

Sixth Circuit overtime ruling favors employer in IC-to-W-2 case

A former Cincinnati Bell employee who sometimes worked 18-hour days has lost his overtime pay appeal after the Sixth Circuit found he qualified for the computer employee exemption under the Fair Labor Standards Act, according to HRMorning. The court affirmed summary judgment for the employer in Bennink v. Cincinnati Bell Telephone Co., rejecting both the FLSA overtime claim and a separate contract claim.

Loren Bennink joined Cincinnati Bell as a W-2 employee in May 2016 after working with the company for several years through an outside vendor. His offer letter listed pay of $75 an hour, and the company paid him $3,000 a week, described as the equivalent of $75 per hour for 40 hours regardless of hours actually worked. The parties disputed whether Bennink was paid hourly or salaried, but agreed his pay exceeded the FLSA computer employee exemption threshold of $27.63 an hour for hourly workers.

Why the computer employee exemption applied

The FLSA computer employee exemption applies to workers whose primary duties involve systems analysis, design, development, documentation, testing or modification of computer systems or programs. The pay threshold is at least $684 a week on a salary basis, or $27.63 an hour if paid hourly.

Bennink argued the interactive voice response system he worked on was not a computer system and that his documentation work amounted to little more than flowcharts. The Sixth Circuit disagreed, finding the system was a computer system and that Bennink helped design, develop and document it by mapping call flows and determining how it should meet user needs.

The court also rejected arguments that Bennink lacked formal computer training and relied on others for programming. The exemption requires no particular degree, education or job title, the court noted. Project-management duties and dependence on other staff for programming did not change the conclusion that his primary duties met the exemption’s requirements.

The contract claim and what it means for offer letters

Bennink separately argued that the $75 hourly rate in his offer letter created a contractual right to pay for every hour worked. The Sixth Circuit rejected that claim, finding the offer letter did not establish an agreement to pay him for all hours worked. The letter itself stated it was not a contract.

This outcome underscores a practical point for HR and payroll teams: offer letters should state clearly whether they create contractual obligations. Many employers already include language that employment is at-will and that the letter does not constitute an employment contract. The Sixth Circuit’s ruling shows how that language can matter when a former employee later claims the letter promised a specific pay arrangement.

Sixth Circuit overtime ruling favors employer in IC-to-W-2 case (illustration)
Photo: Elektrostal. Worker’s payroll book. Plant EZTM. img 02 by Scanning Dmitry Makeev, scan date – 2020 year., Public domain

What this means for employers reclassifying contractors

Bennink’s path from outside vendor to W-2 employee is common. Companies often convert long-term independent contractors to employees after compliance reviews, audits or changes in working relationships. That transition can create confusion about pay structure, exemption status and overtime eligibility.

When a contractor becomes a W-2 employee, HR teams should issue a new offer letter that states the pay basis clearly: hourly or salaried, exempt or non-exempt. If the role is exempt, the letter should name the specific exemption and confirm the pay meets the applicable threshold. Ambiguity about whether someone is paid hourly or salaried invites disputes like the one in this case.

The FLSA computer employee exemption has a higher hourly threshold than the standard salary threshold. Employers paying hourly computer professionals must ensure the rate meets or exceeds $27.63 an hour. For salaried computer employees, the standard $684 weekly threshold applies. State laws may impose higher thresholds, so employers should confirm requirements for their own locations.

Common mistakes when applying the computer employee exemption

One recurring error is assuming that job titles control exemption status. The Sixth Circuit made clear that titles, degrees and formal training are not determinative. A worker with a non-technical title can still qualify if the actual duties meet the exemption’s requirements. Conversely, a worker with an IT title may not qualify if the primary duties fall outside the exemption’s scope.

Another mistake is treating the exemption as covering all technology-adjacent work. The exemption does not apply to employees who merely use computers or software as tools in their jobs. It applies to employees whose primary duties involve creating, designing, developing or modifying computer systems or programs. Help desk staff, for example, generally do not qualify unless their duties go beyond routine support.

Payroll teams should also be careful when paying exempt employees a fixed weekly amount that appears to be based on an hourly rate. The Bennink case shows how a fixed weekly payment described as equivalent to an hourly rate can create ambiguity about whether the employee is salaried or hourly. Clear documentation of the pay basis at hire can reduce that risk.

Steps for HR and payroll teams after this ruling

HR teams reviewing their own practices can take several concrete steps. First, audit current exempt computer employees to confirm their primary duties actually meet the exemption’s requirements. Second, review offer letters for language that could be read as promising hourly pay for exempt roles. Third, confirm that pay for hourly computer professionals meets the $27.63 threshold and that salaried computer employees meet the $684 weekly threshold.

For employees transitioning from contractor to W-2 status, issue a new offer letter that states the exemption status, pay basis and pay amount in plain terms. Include language stating the letter is not a contract if that is the employer’s intent. Keep records of the job description and duties analysis supporting the exemption decision.

The ruling does not change the FLSA’s requirements, but it reinforces that courts will look at actual duties and documented pay arrangements rather than titles, degrees or the parties’ characterizations. Employers with questions about specific roles should consult employment counsel, particularly where state wage laws may impose different or additional requirements.

Sources: HRMorning

Photo: Cybersecurity court document and gavel by Nick Youngson, CC BY-SA 3.0

administrator

Related Articles