Arnott’s Biscuits has secured approval for its new Marleston Manufacturing enterprise agreement, but only after the Fair Work Commission flagged three clauses that appeared to clash with the National Employment Standards, according to HRD America. The Commission approved the Arnott’s (Marleston Manufacturing) Enterprise Agreement 2026 on November 11, with written undertakings from the employer now forming part of the deal.
The agreement, which covers manufacturing employees under the Food, Beverage and Tobacco Manufacturing Award 2020, takes effect on November 18, 2026 and runs until November 11, 2028. The United Workers Union acted as bargaining representative. The Commission also granted a separate application to fix typographical errors, update the table of contents and add page numbers.
The three clauses that drew scrutiny
The first trap concerned public holiday substitution. The agreement allowed the employer and a majority of employees to agree on swapping a public holiday for another day. Under the Fair Work Act 2009, that kind of arrangement can only be made between the employer and an individual employee. A group vote does not satisfy the statutory requirement.
The second trap involved abandonment of employment. A clause stated that a worker absent without reasonable cause during a notice period could be deemed to have abandoned their job and forfeit notice pay. The Commission pointed out that the Act does not strip employees who abandon their employment of the right to minimum notice of termination. The agreement’s own safeguard, a clause stating that the NES prevails wherever there is a conflict, helped limit the damage.
The third trap was a redundancy clause the Commission found appeared broader than the Act allows. The agreement said redundancy entitlements might not apply where an employee had less than one year’s continuous service, potentially leaving workers without redundancy pay they would otherwise be entitled to receive.
How the better-off overall test played out
The Commission also examined whether employees were genuinely better off under the agreement than under the award. Three issues emerged.
Loaded rates for shift workers were set at 25.45 percent above the award, but the Commission found the arrangement vague. It was unclear exactly which entitlements were being rolled into the rate, and whether 25.45 percent actually covered them all.
Level 1 casuals sat just 0.30 percent above the award. The employer submitted that it did not employ level 1 casuals and did not foresee doing so, which satisfied the Commission.
Time off in lieu was allowed at a one-for-one rate, but the agreement was missing two standard award safeguards: the requirement to take time off within six months, and the requirement for unused TOIL to be paid out when employment ends. The employer told the Commission that TOIL was not actually used at the site, with employees banking and taking rostered days off instead. The Commission accepted that explanation.

What this means for payroll and HR teams
The Arnott’s case is a reminder that enterprise agreement approval is not a formality. The Commission actively tests clauses against the NES and the better-off overall test, and employers should expect to defend any provision that departs from award standards.
For payroll teams, the loaded rates issue is the most operationally significant. A loaded rate that does not clearly specify which entitlements it absorbs creates risk on two fronts. First, it may fail the better-off overall test if the margin is not enough to cover the rolled-in entitlements. Second, it creates ongoing payroll ambiguity about what has already been paid and what remains owing.
The required average weekly hours under the agreement are 38.5 hours per week, with the extra half-hour not attracting overtime rates. Payroll teams should verify that time and attendance systems are configured to reflect this before the agreement takes effect.
The TOIL findings also carry a practical lesson. The Commission accepted that TOIL was not used at the site, but that acceptance was specific to the evidence provided. If workplace practice changes and TOIL starts being used, the missing safeguards could become a compliance problem. HR teams should document current practice and review it before each bargaining cycle.
Undertakings as a repair mechanism
The Arnott’s outcome shows how the undertakings process works in practice. Rather than rejecting the agreement outright, the Commission accepted written undertakings from the employer that resolved the identified issues. Those undertakings now form part of the agreement and have the same legal force as the original clauses.
The HRD America article closes with a pointed observation: “Getting the deal across the line is one thing. Getting the clauses right before lodgement is cheaper.” That is the core lesson for employers. Undertakings can fix problems after lodgement, but they add time, require union consultation and leave the final agreement shaped by Commission intervention rather than employer drafting.
For HR teams preparing enterprise agreements, the Arnott’s case suggests a pre-lodgement checklist: review every clause that touches NES entitlements, check public holiday arrangements against the individual-consent requirement, verify redundancy clauses against the Act’s service thresholds, and ensure loaded rates specify exactly which award entitlements they absorb.
| Compliance area | What the agreement said | What the Act requires |
|---|---|---|
| Public holiday substitution | Employer and majority of employees could agree to swap | Agreement only between employer and individual employee |
| Abandonment of employment | Worker absent without cause could forfeit notice pay | Minimum notice of termination still applies |
| Redundancy | Entitlements might not apply under one year’s service | Act sets its own service thresholds for redundancy pay |
The agreement runs until November 11, 2028. Employers with similar clauses in existing agreements should note that the Commission’s reasoning in this decision may signal how similar provisions will be treated in future approval processes.
Sources: HRD America
Photo: Gen. John A. Dix and group, Sanitary Fair Commission - NARA - 524575 by Mathew Benjamin Brady, Public domain

