The Fair Work Commission has found that a Coffs Harbour motel co-manager who held an ABN and invoiced for her work was in fact an employee, not a contractor, according to onnotice.com.au. Commissioner Crawford dismissed a jurisdictional objection raised by Kayenkay Holdings Pty Ltd, which operates the Chelsea Motor Inn in northern New South Wales.
The worker began at the motel in February 2024 as a casual housekeeper and within weeks took on a co-manager position alongside a nephew of Kerrie Hunter, the owner and director of Kayenkay. She registered for an ABN as a sole trader in April 2024 and invoiced the motel for her work. The arrangement ended on 27 April 2026, when Ms Hunter told the worker to move out of her accommodation at the motel. The worker lodged an unfair dismissal application under section 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 on 18 May 2026. Her claim will now proceed to conciliation.
Why an ABN does not settle the question
Australian payroll and HR teams sometimes treat the presence of an ABN and invoice-based payment as proof that a worker is a contractor. This ruling is a reminder that the Fair Work Commission looks past paperwork to the reality of the relationship.
The worker lived on site with her son, worked from 9:00am to 9:00pm for seven consecutive days at a time, and dealt with overnight problems even during her week off. Those facts point to a high degree of control and integration into the business, which are classic indicators of employment under Australian case law. The ABN and invoicing arrangement did not override them.
The key takeaway for employers is that a worker cannot be converted into a contractor simply by asking them to register for an ABN and submit invoices. The Commission will examine how the work is actually performed.
What this means for unfair dismissal exposure
A jurisdictional objection in an unfair dismissal matter is often the first line of defence for an employer. If the worker is a genuine contractor, the Fair Work Commission has no power to hear the claim. If the worker is an employee, the claim can proceed.
In this case, the objection failed. That means the worker cleared the first hurdle and can now pursue conciliation. For the employer, the practical consequence is that misclassification can open the door to unfair dismissal claims, along with potential exposure to unpaid leave, superannuation and other entitlements under the Fair Work Act and related laws.
HR teams should review any arrangement where a worker has an ABN but works set hours, reports to a manager, uses the employer’s premises and equipment, and is not genuinely running their own business. Those are the factors that tend to support an employment finding.

Practical checks for Australian employers
Employers who engage workers on ABNs should test the arrangement against the indicators the Commission and courts apply. A useful starting point is to ask whether the worker:
- Controls their own hours and place of work
- Bears financial risk and can make a profit or loss
- Provides their own tools and equipment
- Can delegate or subcontract the work
- Works for multiple clients
The more the answers point to the employer controlling the work, the higher the risk that the worker is an employee at law. This is not a box-ticking exercise. A written contract that says “contractor” will not protect an employer if the day-to-day reality says otherwise.
Payroll teams should also be aware that superannuation obligations can apply to contractors who are engaged wholly or principally for their personal labour, even if the worker is not an employee for other purposes. The tests are not identical across all laws, which is why misclassification can create problems in more than one area.
Deadlines and next steps
The worker in this case lodged her unfair dismissal application on 18 May 2026, within the 21-day statutory timeframe that applies from the date dismissal takes effect. Employers facing similar claims should note that jurisdictional objections must be raised early and supported by evidence about the actual working relationship.
For HR and payroll leaders, the immediate step after reading this ruling is to audit any current ABN arrangements where the worker is embedded in the business, works regular hours, and is not operating independently. Where the risk is high, seek advice before the relationship ends. The cost of correcting classification now is likely to be far lower than defending a claim later.
| Factor | Contractor indicator | Employee indicator |
|---|---|---|
| Hours | Worker sets own hours | Employer sets fixed hours |
| Risk | Worker bears financial risk | Employer bears the risk |
| Equipment | Worker provides own tools | Employer provides tools and premises |
| Delegation | Worker can subcontract | Worker must perform work personally |
| Clients | Worker serves multiple clients | Worker serves one business |
The Fair Work Commission’s decision does not create a new legal test, but it does show how readily an ABN and invoicing arrangement can be set aside when the working relationship looks like employment in practice. Employers should treat the ABN as a red flag to investigate, not a shield against liability.
Sources: onnotice.com.au
Photo: Reception hall of the Village Motel (Tournus) by Tangopaso, Public domain

